How to choose the right asset manager in Singapore: Suitability vs Fiduciary Standards of Financial Advisors

How to Choose the Right Asset Manager in Singapore: Suitability vs Fiduciary Standards of Financial Advisors

Fiduciary vs Suitability Standards

Independent vs Commission Structures

Financial advisors in Singapore are required to adhere to a set of rules and regulations aimed at protecting the interests of consumers. However, there are two standards which they follow know as the fiduciary and suitability standards. Fiduciary advisors provide independent advice and only earn through the client instead of commission on products they sell. This lets them provide client-focused recommendations based on transparency and trust. On the other hand, suitability advisors may charge lower upfront fees and have more investment options, but may have potential conflicts of interest and less transparency as they earn commission on the products they sell. It is essential to consider your financial goals and personal preferences before choosing between a suitability or fiduciary advisor. Clients should also ask questions, assess the advisor’s qualifications and reputation, and evaluate the fees before engaging their services.

Fiduciary Standards: Advantages and Disadvantages

Advantages:

  1. Client-focused recommendations: Fiduciary advisors in Singapore are required to recommend financial products that are suitable and appropriate for the client’s financial situation and goals.
  2. Transparency: Fiduciary advisors in Singapore are required to disclose their conflicts of interest and how they are compensated for their services, providing clients with greater transparency.
  3. Trust: Clients can trust that their fiduciary advisor is working in their best interest and not recommending investments based on their own financial gain.

Disadvantages:

  1. Higher upfront costs: Fiduciary advisors in Singapore typically charge higher upfront fees than advisors who operate under the suitability standard, which can be a disadvantage for some clients.
  2. Limited investment options: Fiduciary advisors in Singapore are limited to recommending only investments that are in the best interest of the client, which can limit investment options for clients. For example, fiduciary advisors may not recommend products you are personally interested in like high risk assets like crypto or derivatives.

Fiduciary Standards: Advantages and Disadvantages

Advantages:

  1. Lower upfront costs: Advisors who operate under the suitability standard in Singapore typically charge lower annual fees than fiduciary advisors, which can be beneficial for clients who are looking for cost-effective financial advice. However, while they may earn lower on management fees, they could be earning even more from their clients through the commission on products they sell to clients.
  2. More investment options: Advisors who operate under the suitability standard in Singapore have a wider range of investment options to recommend to clients, which can be beneficial for clients who are looking for a specific type of investment. Suitability advisors could act more like agents who could source any investment product the client is looking for within their means.

Disadvantages:

  1. Potential conflicts of interest: Advisors who operate under the suitability standard in Singapore may have conflicts of interest that could impact their recommendations, such as receiving commissions on the sale of certain investment products. Ill-matched products with high commissions could lead the client to lose money in the long term.
  2. Less transparency: Advisors who operate under the suitability standard in Singapore are not required to disclose their conflicts of interest or how they are compensated for their services, which can make it more difficult for clients to determine if their advisor is working in their best interest.

Who are the fiduciary vs suitability advisors in Singapore?

Suitability advisors in Singapore include financial advisors who work for banks, insurance companies, and independent financial advisory firms. Typically these advisors work for firms who also sell their own in-house products. These advisors may recommend a range of financial products, such as insurance policies, mutual funds, and unit trusts, matching the products of the bank/insurance firms with the clients goals.

Fiduciary advisors in Singapore include independent asset managers such as multi-family offices and independent asset management firms who operate under the fiduciary standard of care. The promise of independence means that they should not be receiving commissions through products and are required to act in the best interests of their clients and provide advice that is free from any conflicts of interest and provide investment advice that is suitable for the client’s risk profile and financial goals.

It’s important to note that some financial advisors in Singapore may operate under both the suitability and fiduciary standards depending on the specific products or services being recommended. Clients should always ask their financial advisor about their standard of care and any potential conflicts of interest before engaging their services.

Which is right for you?

Choosing between a suitability or fiduciary advisor in Singapore ultimately depends on your personal preferences, financial goals, and the complexity of your financial situation. Here are some factors to consider when making your decision:

  1. Understand the difference: As discussed earlier, a suitability advisor in Singapore is required to recommend financial products that are suitable for your needs and goals, while a fiduciary advisor is required to act in your best interests and provide advice that is free from any conflicts of interest. Understanding the difference between these two standards can help you determine which type of advisor is more suitable for your needs.
  2. Assess your financial situation: If you have a complex financial situation, such as owning a business or having a large investment portfolio, a fiduciary advisor may be more suitable for you as they are required to act in your best interests and provide tailored advice that takes into account your unique circumstances.
  3. Consider the advisor’s qualifications: Look for an advisor who has the necessary qualifications and experience to provide sound financial advice. 
  4. Check the advisor’s reputation: Look for an advisor who has a good reputation in the industry and has a track record of providing reliable financial advice. You can check for reviews online or ask for referrals from family and friends.
  5. Evaluate the fees: Consider the fees charged by the advisor, as this can impact the overall cost of the financial advice you receive. Fiduciary advisors in Singapore may charge higher fees than suitability advisors, so it’s important to consider the cost-benefit of each option.
  6. Ask questions: Finally, ask questions to understand the advisor’s approach to financial planning, how they are compensated, and how they manage potential conflicts of interest. This can help you make an informed decision and choose an advisor who is aligned with your financial goals and values.

Connect with our partners

If you’re looking for independent asset managers to advise on your investments, send us an inquiry at [email protected] or use the contact form below:


Share Article:
Singapore Finance
Singapore Finance

Singapore Finance is an editorial dedicated to navigating Singapore’s financial system, connecting you to Singapore’s professional services.